I listened to the USA v. Slovinia World Cup (soccer) game last week. I'm not a soccer fan, but it's pretty exciting to think about how one sport's crown jewel draws people together. The reports I'm reading say more than a billion people will watch the World Cup. It's a huge collaborative effort on the part of FIFA (the sport's governing body), the South African government, private industry (hotels, restaurants, vuvuzela vendors), participating countries and worldwide media.
It's also a collaborative effort on the part of the premier soccer leagues of Europe and South America -- to loan out players who play for country, rather than club. The effort stakeholders put forward to make the event meaningful for fans is astonishing (coincidentally, it generates truckloads of revenue for FIFA and the host economy).
Moreover, it makes me wonder what our organizations and associations in general are doing to collaborate with stakeholders, members and non-members to generate excitement, create value and foster passion among our "fans?"
I contrast this with a sport which has a history of not playing well together -- major college football (American Football, that is). Despite the promise of a huge payday from a Division I football playoff system, the NCAA and BCS have essentially designed a system to keep a few powerhouse players in control. And recently, a few league executives decided they'd expand their conferences to stake claim to larger TV contracts. This led to speculation that the Big 10 would add up to five new members, the Pac 10 would match them and others would follow suit to insure revenue parody.
One of the conferences, the Big 12, was at the center of speculation because the leagues' TV contract brought in less revenue than other conferences and didn't share revenue equally among members (whether equal is fair is another story). Most of the revenue went to powerhouse programs at the University of Texas and University of Oklahoma. And there was a lot of talk about what would happen to the Big 12 if this member or that member left for another conference.
When the Big 10 came courting new members -- University of Missouri (my alma mater), Kansas and Nebraska -- listened because they offered a better value: equal revenue-sharing among members and more money than they were currently receiving from the Big 12.
But this ruffled the feathers of other conference members and caused more speculation on where Texas (Pac 10?) and the Big 12 (disbanded?) would end up.
In the end, University of Colorado and University of Nebraska left the Big 12. Legendary Nebraska coach Tom Osborne may as well have given Texas the finger at the press conference.
And the remaining Big 12 members presented Texas and Oklahoma with a lopsided revenue package so they could "save" the conference. On one hand, the weaker, remaining members used their collaborative clout to get a better television deal and save traditional rivalries, but clearly the interests of the few were served, rather than the interests of the whole. The maneuvering and posturing made two powerful members (Texas, Oklahoma) more powerful while keeping Missouri, Iowa State, Kansas and others on a lower tier.
Organizations have a duty to serve their members' best interests. When a few members manipulate the association to personal benefit, it robs the organization of value for others. A rising tide should lift all ships, not force others to run aground.
In the current economy, there are many opportunities for associations to work together with other nonprofits, vendors and corporations to provide value to members. We may not reach 1 billion screaming, passionate fans, but by collaborating with stakeholders within our industries, rather than conspiring against them, we can generate more engaged members and build value for our associations.
Here's another recent article on organizational collaboration from
Associations NOW:
http://www.asaecenter.org/PublicationsResources/ANowDetail.cfm?ItemNumber=50767
Economic Impact of the World Cup:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_the_FIFA_World_Cup
Conference Expansion Winners and Losers (from a fellow Mizzou J-School grad):
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/columns/story?columnist=forde_pat&id=5291319